EMI, Sony BMG, Universal Music, and Warner Music take Eircom to court to force it to begin blocking illegal P2P downloads of copyrighted music.
In what’s being called a first of its kind in the war on illegal file-sharing by copyright holders in Ireland, the so-called “Big 4″ music labels have banded together to sue the Irish ISP Eircom in order to force it to begin blocking P2P music downloads by its subscribers.
They want Eircom to begin using filtering software that prevents its customers from using P2P and file-sharing services to illegally download copyrighted music despite the fact that existing law in that country makes no requirement that it monitor the traffic on its network for illegal behavior.
Previously, cases of illegal file-sharing merely targeted individual users and not network service providers themselves.
Willie Kavanagh, managing director of EMI Ireland, said in a brief statement that “…the record industry was experiencing a ‘dramatic and accelerating’ decline in income and that Eircom was ‘well aware’ its facilities were being used to violate the property rights of record companies ‘on a grand scale.’”
Solicitors – Eurospeak for lawyers – for Eircom point out, as mentioned above, that it has no existing legal obligation to monitor network traffic for illegal behavior. It’s a point that shouldn’t be taken lightly considering the possible fallout from such a requirement that could follow.
Imagine, for instance, if an ISP allowed a site that promoted radical action that resulted in death or injury. Would victims and their families be allowed to sue and hold them liable for “facilitating” the performance of the deed? Furthermore, where would the ISP’s responsibility to monitor network traffic begin and where would it end?
Related Posts
- Record Labels Target More Irish ISPs for “Three-Strikes”
- Irish Record Industry Sues ISP for Illegal File-Sharing on its Network
- Irish ISP Agrees to Three-Strikes Policy for File-Sharers
- Irish ISP Agrees to Block BitTorrent Tracker Sites
- Record labels count cost of music piracy
Loading ...
I don’t know what the laws in Europe are but the U.S. has network neutrality and Comcast is in trouble for blocking bittorrent.
Unless I’m mistaken the net neutrality debate is still ongoing. Anyway if they do win this case I hope people cry foul corporations shouldn’t be messing with the internet to mold it in their image. Its just a slippery slope that will kill it off.
Guess this means we’ll all have to start wearing our balaclava helmets I know it’s not much but at least it’ll give us some anonimity at local level.. they can’t have it ALL their own way..