Aug 13 2007

European Youth on Illegal File-Sharing: ‘Music Artists Don’t Need My Money!’

  • Written by soulxtc
  • 7 Comments


European Commission’s “Safer Internet for Children” study details how children are aware of the risks of illegal file-sharing and how they justify it.

The European Commission’s Directorate-General Information Society and Media has commissioned a qualitative study on the subject of “Safer Internet for Children.”

This study covers 29 countries, the 27 Member States, as well as Iceland and Norway, and involves boys and girls in age groups 9 to 10 and 12 to 14 whom all have the possibility to access and use the internet at least once per month.

The goal is to improve knowledge of internet and mobile phone usage of children as well as their online behavior and perceptions of risk and safety that are associated with it, all with the purpose in mind of creating an overall “Safer Internet Programme.”

Chapter IV of the study is what details the participant’s thoughts on illegal downloading. It concludes that “In the vast majority of cases, across all countries, children know that most of the downloads are illegal, but they minimize, deny or justify the practice.” In fact, for the very large majority of the study’s participants, there is a considerable “feeling of impunity” and, in a way, the conviction of a form of “legitimacy”, if not legality, in downloading. In many of their minds, whether or not it is “illegal” is not always clear. .

From the study:

  • “Everyone does it”, the mass nature of the behavior “putting it in the clear” to some degree (“why not me, too?”) but also making the sanction very difficult and not very credible. Moreover, the example set by parents (who themselves often like downloading things) constitutes, in the children’s eyes, an implicit form of authorisation.
  • The download is for personal and private purposes, and therefore less serious than systematic recording for fraudulent resale.
  • The websites are assumed to remunerate the artists.
  • The argument of the harm inflicted on artists is not very admissible and not very credible.
  • CDs and DVD are too expensive, and most children cannot afford them.
    “It’s illegal, but it does not look like it is illegal” (Boys group, 12-14 years, Denmark)
    “But I do not understand that it is illegal” (Girls group, 9-10 years, Belgium)
    “It is wrong but not our fault” (Girls group, 12-14 years, Belgium)
    “Downloading is illegal, it is not punishable whereas sharing the files is punishable” (Boys
    group, 12-14 years, Finland)
    “Dad does it all the time” (Girls group, 12-14 years, Norway)
    “People download, but if is just for themselves, it is less serious than downloading for burning
    and reselling” (Boys group, 12-14 years, France)
    “I don’t really feel guilty. It wouldn’t be on the Internet if it was like really illegal, they
    wouldn’t have it there” (Boys group, 12-14 years, United-Kingdom)
    “They have a lot of money ! They don’t need my money” (Boys group, 12-14 years, Czech
    Republic)
    “I really don’t care, it’s not my problem. Singers and actors are rich enough” (All groups,
    Italy)
    “We pay because we are spending megabits !” (Boys group, 12-14 years, Portugal)

Moreover, only a minority of the study’s participants said they were aware of the harm created by illegal file-sharing and the “immorality” of this behavior. Almost all of them even stated they will continue to “carry on downloading.” and do not see themselves “refraining from doing it”(take that RIAA).

One bit of good news for the the MPAA and RIAA though is that some study participants did suggest “clearer rules” were in order, suggesting the possibility of following, them, and that there was also the chance that they be inclined to make a “modest payment” in order to download content online.

At the end of the day, the study found that lawsuits and other legal threats were not the biggest deterrent against illegal file-sharing, but instead was the risk of downloading a virus.

digg_url = ‘http://digg.com/tech_news/Euro_Youth_on_Illegal_File_Sharing_Music_Artists_Don_t_Need_My_Money’;

Looking for more stuff to watch or download?
3 Quick Ways to Watch Movies for FREE!
3 quick ways to watch TV shows for FREE
BitTorrent torrent sites & search engines
Azureus – A Beginner’s Guide to BitTorrent Downloading
uTorrent – A Beginner’s guide to BitTorrent downloading
Watch The Simpsons, The Office, Jackass, South Park, Lost, X-Men, and More, On-Demand For Free
News Tip? Comment? Suggestion? jared@zeropaid.com
bed

Related Posts

  1. Two Out of Three American Teens Oppose Fines for Music File Sharers, Says Harris Interactive Youth Survey
  2. SURVEY: Illegal music downloading by youth drops 40%
  3. Singapore police in 25 new cases of illegal music file-sharing
  4. UK Engineeering Firm raided in Illegal File-Sharing Probe
  5. 1st Norwegian charged with illegal file-sharing for running DC Hub
Zeropaid on Facebook

Comments

  1. VAMPYRE BLADE

    Both of these describe how i feel.
    “They have a lot of money ! They don’t need my money” (Boys group 12-14 years Czech

    Republic)

    “I really don’t care it’s not my problem. Singers and actors are rich enough” (All groups

    Italy)

  2. Signa

    you know i dont have a good phrase to justify myself. maybe “im paying for the net so im entitled to anything on it.” and “~$20 per CD/DVD is retarded. im going to buy whats worth it and download the rest.” sums up how i feel.

  3. Kewbase

    Strange that they did not quote children from The Netherlands. Could it be because even children know that downloading is legal in The Netherlands? There must be more countries with the same legislation i guess?

  4. Kewbase

    I just read the Dutch report. Here is a quote “Downloading through Limewire is not illegal otherwise it would be not online anymore.” (Girls
    group 9-10).
    Good to know even ten year olds got the facts straight.;)

  5. soulxtc

    @Kewbase
    Thats so awesome…….

  6. Shackles

    Great job kiddies hop on your favorite file sharing protocal and download away. I just wanna give you all mass cuddles =^^=. Pirate Away boys and girls pirate away! Yaaaarg!

  7. StormNinja

    Does my pirate booty looting heart good to know I am not alone….

Trackbacks url:

Leave a Comment...

  • Advertisement

    Giganews Newsgroups

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Loading ... Loading ...

  • mpsharp.com Blog » Watching NFL games online: [...] show you a number of streams to choose from for each game.  All the streams require some sort of StreamTorrent pl...
  • ejonesss: no it is not going to completely stop piracy because while it will stop those whose reason for piracy is quality it is n...
  • file sharing anonymously - P2Pfreak.com: [...] and Trusty Files) just google any one of them and you will get some great info. also here IP filtering with uTorr...
  • soulxtc: Wasn't aware people were guaranteed jobs...
  • mountain_rage: BTW Youtube is supposed to go 1080P soon :D....
  • Gibbbo: Unfortunately the European stores still don't have anything close to the selection available in the USA store. I'm buyin...
  • STUDY: Artists Earn More in a P2P World: [...] personal favorite is the “The Impact of Music Downloads and P2P File-Sharing on the Purchase of Music: A Study F...
  • D.AN: So a stupid plan has been become a doubly-retarded plan....
  • sdsd