Nov 14 2006

Perspective: The farce behind ‘Digital Freedom’

  • Written by soulxtc
  • No Comments

Last month, the Consumer Electronics Association and other groups announced a “Digital Freedom” campaign that latches onto the concept of fair use–supposedly to benefit consumers.

Seems like a worthwhile effort. But in truth, it’s merely a return to an increasingly used playbook, an extremist interpretation of fair use to frighten and mislead consumers and policymakers.

Like a trademark that becomes generic, the fair use doctrine is in danger of losing its meaning and value if CEA’s self-serving claims are taken at face value. CEA has twisted and contorted “fair use” beyond its true intent, turning it into a free pass for those who simply don’t want to pay for creative works.
Critics like CEA sometimes lose sight of the fact that record labels and other copyright owners are as dependent on fair use as consumers.

So what is fair use, really? It’s codified in section 107 of the Copyright Act, intended primarily to promote such uses as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship or research. The determination is further guided by four factors–including purpose of use, the type of work, the amount used, and the effect on the market for or value of the work–which must be balanced to establish whether a particular use is “fair.” It is not an all-purpose excuse to make use of someone else’s property for free. And it is certainly not an excuse to boost the sales of electronic devices and services on the backs of hard-working creators.

Related Posts

  1. Free speech under Net attack, study says
  2. USC copyright rules are flawed
  3. Copyright hindering scholarship in the humanities and social sciences
  4. Digital Freedom Campaign Begins, Claims Right to Download Movies, Music
  5. USC’s bizarre, non-legal copyright policy
Zeropaid on Facebook

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Trackbacks url:

Leave a Comment...

Giganews Newsgroups


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Loading ... Loading ...

  • D.AN: "... the basic system [...] is Capitalist. Trying to change that [...] just means there will be a lot of corporation own...
  • D.AN: You seem to have the misinformation that file-sharers are part of one group. However, that is not true. "Even ideas, ...
  • D.AN: Ignorant you are, malgre....
  • D.AN: So you agree that you act based on accusation, malgre....
  • D.AN: Does the public require "a *right* to access the creations of others" if those creations are put in public by the creato...
  • D.AN: malgre, we don't care about what you think, so we also don't need your life story in speculative form....
  • D.AN: "... it just suggests SOME SORT of link between file sharing and music sales." IFPI and related industries also sugge...
  • john o: would appreciate an invite to iptorrents as demonoid is still down. if i am lucky then Thank U. ...
  • sdsd