Dec 22 2002

Judge finds Madster in contempt

  • Written by Music Pirate
  • No Comments

Source: newsobserver.com

The file-sharing service Madster and its founder could face $51,000 in fines for violating a court order barring the swapping of copyright songs.

U.S. District Judge Marvin Aspen in Chicago found Madster and Johnny Deep in contempt of court Friday. He scheduled a Jan. 23 hearing on the fines. Deep said he had no comment on the ruling.

On Oct. 30, Aspen issued a preliminary injunction against Madster after finding evidence the Albany-based service had violated copyright law. The injunction called for Madster to monitor its system and disable access to copyright works.

Recording companies suing Madster claimed the service was disregarding Aspen’s initial injunction, so on Dec. 2 a federal judge ordered the Albany-based service to immediately shut down. Download links on the Madster site have been unavailable since then.

The $51,000 in possible fines amounts to $1,500 for each of the 34 days between the two orders.

“John Deep was held in contempt for a very good reason. He refused to comply with the court’s order, arguing that it was not possible to prevent illegal downloading and uploading on his network,” said Matt Oppenheim, senior vice president of business and legal affairs at the Recording Industry Association of America.

“Only after the record companies filed a motion for contempt did Deep turn his system off – thereby proving his argument false.”

Deep said he didn’t know if the file-sharing service was still operating.

Madster changed its name from Aimster as part of a settlement with America Online, whose instant-messaging service is abbreviated AIM.

Lawsuits involving Madster and media companies were consolidated in Chicago, although that litigation was put on hold in March after bankruptcy filings were made by Deep and two companies involved in the service’s operations.

A bankruptcy judge in Albany lifted the stay for the limited purpose of allowing plaintiffs to seek the preliminary injunction motion.

Related Posts

  1. Judge Grants Reprieve to Madster
  2. Madster told to pull the plug, resists court order
  3. Madster Removes its Own Lawyer
  4. Madster to take case to the supreme court
  5. Aimster/Madster Files For Bankruptcy
Zeropaid on Facebook

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Trackbacks url:

Leave a Comment...

Giganews Newsgroups


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars Loading ... Loading ...

  • @TheHuxCapacitor: Hmmm, Couple of things for me - There's no causal relationship proven in the study between P2P and decline in sales...
  • Stan: I would love to get Ayn Rand's perspective on this situation. The labels may have changed, but the selfishness, ...
  • soulxtc: Actually no. See this > http://i64.photobucket.com/albums/h187/soulxtc/ip... (From http://www.zeropaid.com/news/10021...
  • soulxtc: Actually no. See this > http://i64.photobucket.com/albums/h187/soulxtc/ip... (From http://www.zeropaid.com/news/10021...
  • PekkaK: The discussion about copyright has long ago transcended the question of whether anyone has the right to steal or copy or...
  • Debbie: hi could I please get an invite please. I was a member of Demonoid but is down.Thanks. ...
  • D.AN: "... the basic system [...] is Capitalist. Trying to change that [...] just means there will be a lot of corporation own...
  • D.AN: You seem to have the misinformation that file-sharers are part of one group. However, that is not true. "Even ideas, ...
  • sdsd