Test Drive Improved News Comments

[Jorge]

I have been working on a improved solution for the news comments for the past couple weeks and i am ready to let some of you test em.

I still have some modifications to work on, but you can test drive the system if you like.

Test Drive Comments

[serrebi101]

seems to work well...

[Vampmon]

I dont think it worked for me, posted a comment, it didn't come up, then refreshed and no comments were there, asked me to post another comment?

[cpugeniusmv]

It doesn't work without JavaScript.

IE threw up the debugger. I did a quick look, couldn't find specifically where it's talking about.

You can't see previous comments until after you've posted a comment (unless you click View Full Thread and go to the forums...)

Other than that...it seems to "work."

[cpugeniusmv]

And the tab order is screwed up.

[Jorge]

It doesn't work without JavaScript.

CPU, so was there an error in the code, thus why you were getting the popup?

[Jorge]

And the tab order is screwed up.

This is on my task list.

[Jorge]

i see that there are a few problems. i am getting a JS error all of a sudden.

[cpugeniusmv]

CPU, so was there an error in the code, thus why you were getting the popup?

The JavaScript debugger error in IE and not working without JavaScript aren't related.

My guess is that there's an object in use that IE doesn't correctly implement.

I only pointed out that it doesn't work without JavaScript because in all the hype about "AJAX," people tend to forget about backwards compatibility with non-javascript-capable browsers.