PDA

View Full Version : Renewing the push to collect Net taxes


View Full Version : Renewing the push to collect Net taxes


Ne007
September 11th, 2005, 07:41 PM
State officials plan to revive this fall their push to force Internet and mail-order vendors to collect sales taxes from their out-of-state customers.

On Oct. 1, 13 states will officially launch reformed systems that pledge compliance with the Streamlined Sales Tax Agreement, first devised in 2002 by a committee of state tax officials and billed as a way to make tax administration simpler and more uniform. Five more states have passed laws that, over the next two years, will bring them into compliance with the agreement.

Compliance with the system won't change the fact that tax collection remains voluntary for companies without a physical presence in the states where their orders originate, thanks to a 1992 Supreme Court decision.

But project backers say they hope the streamlined system, even with voluntary compliance, would attract participation from multistate companies that say the current tax system is too complicated.

"In some ways, this has absolutely nothing to do with the Internet," said project co-chair Scott Peterson of the South Dakota Department of Revenue. "What we're trying to do is simplify sales tax administration, whether that's for the downtown hardware store, 1-800-Flowers, or Walmart.com."

That means smoothing over differences among state tax procedures. For example, some states distinguish soft drinks from food when deciding tax rates on each, but the definition of soft drink varies widely, Peterson said. His project's solution? "Anything with less than 50 percent juice is considered a soft drink," he said. "Fifty percent or more, it's considered food."

Read the Rest Here:
http://news.com.com/Renewing+the+push+to+collect+Net+taxes/2100-1028_3-5855343.html?tag=nefd.lede

truelyme
September 17th, 2005, 07:14 PM
This is an attempted tax grab. Make no mistake about it. The state of South Dakota is attempting to hiest this off as tax simplicity to divert attention from a very basic tenant about taxes. In the US there is no taxation without representation. That has been the stumbling block of legality for states in taxing the internet. Yet somehow many states have passed it. Now I can understand them taxing their own citizens as they are indeed represented. So homestate taxation works.

What doesn't work is sales from outside the stste. Here is the attempted grab. Those from outside the state have NO REPRESENTATION while being taxed. Of course you noticed the voluntary side of the comment. That particular hope shows the taxation isn't really workable. I certainly won't volunteer to pay taxes where they aren't due. You can bet at somepoint down the road they will attempt to make this "voluntarty" part mandentory.