PDA

View Full Version : Being Sued By The RIAA Turns Profitable


View Full Version : Being Sued By The RIAA Turns Profitable


Kooperman
September 12th, 2003, 05:29 PM
Being Sued by the RIAA Turns Profitable
September 12, 2003
Thomas Mennecke

What started off as every P2P users nightmare has turned into a profitable enterprise for 12 year old Brianna LaHara. Like 60 million other American citizens, Brianna’s downloading day started off like many others; launch your Kazaa client and trade away.

Unfortunately for Brianna, she had approximately 1,000 copyrighted songs in her shared directory. Compounding her situation was the type of shared music; mostly top 40, such as Christina Aguilera. This unfortunate combination is exactly what the RIAA automatons are looking for.

Like many other victims of the RIAA's persecution of the American people, Brianna had no idea that she was targeted until reporters started contacting the household. The RIAA quickly brushed off the issue, accepting a minimal payment of $2,000.

While the marginal penalty may seem like a fortune to this low-income New York family, the immediate sympathy and outpouring was undeniable. Almost immediately, P2P United, a trade organization that promote the file-sharing world, sent the family $2,000 to cover the costs.

However, the support didn't stop there.

In addition to the 2 grand from P2P United, Brianna has literally been flooded with donations. The donations range anywhere from $3 dollars to nearly $1,000. Not only has Brianna been able to pay her fine; she's making a profit from her ordeal with the RIAA.

In addition, "Rochester, New York radio disc jockey Brother Wease also offered to pay Torres’ legal bill, and online music retailer MusicRebellion.com said it would allow Torres’ daughter, Brianna Lahara, to download $2,000 worth of free music from its industry-sanctioned site."

What started off as a financial nightmare for the LaHara family has turned into a dream come true. With the $2,000 dollar offer from Music Rebellion, and “floods” of donations where some have totaled near $1,000, we can only speculate that Brianna has managed to make over $4,000 for the LaHara household - and that's a very conservative estimate. Not bad for being sued for copyright infringement.

This situation should serve as wake up call for the RIAA. Their narrow-minded vision is tantamount to the communist witch-hunts conducted by Senator McCarthy in the 1950’s. Much like we look bad and say “shame” on such freedom violations, we must continue our resistance against this tyranny so the next generation doesn’t say the same about our time.

http://www.slyck.com/news.php?story=238

shawners
September 12th, 2003, 05:45 PM
Hey the money most people save on music, can lead others to donate to EFF.. Or ones facing a terrible lawsuit. It just shows the RIAA that everyone in the file sharing community thats aware of their ordeal, will help in any way necessary.
As a twig we can break in half.. But once their are thousands of twigs.. it cant break!

Evil_Dweller_01
September 12th, 2003, 05:57 PM
LoL

Now she can share 2,000 songs $2 dollars each...

Just kidding!

I guess she's lucky...

REDO
September 12th, 2003, 06:13 PM
if the $2000 dollars got paid, I would donate the leftover to the EFF.

rainbowdemon
September 12th, 2003, 06:16 PM
It wouldn't really be honest for her to keep that money, but after the way the riaa treated her, it would be hard not to. Sounds like the beginning of a good college fund.

Sephiroth
September 12th, 2003, 08:21 PM
Seems to me when they found out that they were sueing a 12 year old they said "Oh shit." and tried to very quickly to brush this one under the carpet because it would cause massive pr problems.

The record companies are trying to become like cable tv. The problem with that is that i dont think anyone is going to pay-per-listen or monthy fees to listen to music since many people dont listen to alot of music so it wouldnt be worth it.

Their attack methods the RIAA president Cory Sherman said were doing what the cable companies do.

Which they think they have the control over everything like cable but they dont so it will never work and which is why their propoganda and bully tatics are failing. And when they piss people off a pr campagin isnt going to win me back and i dont think many others will be swayed.

But after they started sueing people and after that was not acting like the deterrent they hoped it was then one company of the many that make up the RIAA finally lowers the price of CDs.

Malicious Intent
September 13th, 2003, 02:16 AM
Wouldn't it have been better for all that money to go to other people who have been sued?